top of page

Why New Architecture Sucks

2 days ago
3 min read
McDonaldization of modern design
McDonaldization of modern design

Architecture begins once the function is fulfilled. The most important aspect of design is, how it makes you feel and what it means. The way an object or space makes you feel is what separates a bunker from boutique hotel. Both can give you a place to sleep. The difference is how you feel when you see it, walk next to it, and walk through the door.

Today, corporations do not make products that people love. They just make it barely good enough to push potential buyers toward a purchasing decision. It often works better if you try to design and sell the product at extreme scale. It’s cheap enough to justify, familiar enough to feel comfortable, and it works well enough to do the job. So, if the goal is to maximize the profit, the best thing you can do is not make a product that a few people really love but instead sell the product that clears the lowest hurdle for the largest number of people. It's just corporate greed and indifference masquerading as minimalism. Corporate efficiency is the only meaning left in today's architecture and design.


  • Chain hotels. A small Art Deco hotel can be the place you remember twenty years later. A chain hotel can win the booking because you know what the room will look like, it’s near where you need to be, and you can use your points.

  • McDonald's is the most profitable restaurant in the world. Think of the best burger in your neighborhood. You’d go out of your way for it. McDonald’s built a business around being the burger you barely have to go out of your way for. It led all U.S. limited-service chains in 2024 with $53.5 billion in systemwide sales. Vast (stupid) majority will always choose comfort over novelty and quality.

  • Generic glass condo towers. A buyer can love the view from the 20th floor and feel nothing for the building from the sidewalk. The sales brochure shows you the ocean from the balcony. It never shows you what a block of identical modular balconies does to the street.

  • Suburban strip malls. A strip mall can be a perfectly rational choice for each shopper who needs to park, pick up a prescription, and get home. Add up those choices and you can get a commercially successful place where almost nobody would go for a walk, or really want to be outside of accomplishing the errand.

  • Cars. A buyer can make a perfectly sensible choice based on price, cargo space, fuel economy, and a comfortable ride. The manufacturer gets a vehicle it can sell to commuters, families, and retirees. You end up with a parking lot full of cars that are hard to tell apart.

Volvo then and now
Volvo then and now

“Good enough” sounds harmless when you’re booking a room, buying a car, or picking up dinner. But make it the standard for every building, every storefront, and every product, and you end up with a world that works well enough and gives you very little to care about. A developer counts how many condos sold. Generations spend lifetimes walking past the generic meaningless buildings.

The magic of small-scale courtyards
The magic of small-scale courtyards

Historic buildings make people stop and look. They evoke wonder and delight. You can feel the care someone took

in deciding where a line should end, how far a ledge should project, and what the entrance should look like after dark. You can see the stories these buildings are telling. A room upstairs gives you a place to sleep. The building gives you a reason to remember where you slept. Call that "extra" if you like. Strip enough of it away and you’re back to a bunker, only now the brochure calls it luxury.


 
 
 

Comments


Copyright © 2026 Miami Deco Tours

bottom of page